Blog

At-Home Lyme Tick Tests: Is a Negative Result Really Good News?

Are at-home Lyme tick tests reliable? Learn how antigen test strips compare with lab PCR, why a negative may not mean safe, and what to do after a tick bite.

Key Takeaways

  • At-home Lyme tick tests are not new: an antigen-based test strip was sold more than a decade ago.
  • Antigen-based lateral-flow strips detect proteins and cannot copy their target, so they are generally less sensitive than laboratory PCR.
  • A test for one Lyme bacterium cannot rule out other tick-borne pathogens, and crushing the tick can prevent species identification.
  • Tick testing cannot tell you whether you have been infected. Talk to a healthcare professional about symptoms or preventive treatment.
Imagine finding a tick attached to your skin after a weekend outdoors. You remove it, crush it in a small tube, add a few drops to a test strip, and voilà! Within minutes you receive the best-case result: NEGATIVE.

More than a decade ago, the Care Plus Tick-Test was sold in Europe and later introduced in Canada, offering an at-home test that used a color-changing strip to detect Lyme-related Borrelia bacteria in a crushed tick.

Historical Care Plus Tick-Test kit with a tick, test tube, pipette and lateral-flow test cassette
An at-home tick test sold more than a decade ago used an antibody test strip to check a crushed tick for Lyme bacteria.

How Does the At-Home Tick Test Work?

You order a test kit, follow the step-by-step instructions to process your tick, then interpret your results based on the lines appearing on a test strip.

That sounds simple, but it’s a hands-on job. For a quick answer, you need to have bought the kit before the bite; otherwise you’re waiting for it to arrive in the mail. Then you work through the multi-step instructions, much like the at-home COVID test. Unlike a nasal swab, though, your sample is a tick. It may be alive, tiny, broken into pieces, or so engorged that crushing it becomes a messy job.

Interpreting the result is up to you too. A faint or unclear line may leave you guessing, or you may have to download an app for assistance. When you send your tick to a laboratory like Ticknology, trained staff identify the tick and process it under controlled conditions, using validated PCR testing with built-in quality controls, and a Ph.D.-level scientist reviews and signs your results.

How Does Lateral-Flow Sensitivity Compare with Laboratory PCR?

qPCR amplifies the target DNA itself, and the fluorescent signal grows with every copy made. Antigen-based lateral-flow tests can only enhance the signal from whatever protein is already present.

With respect to Care Plus Tick-Test (the version sold in Europe at the time), a 2013 study by Sprong et al. (Parasites & Vectors, 6:338) raised serious concerns about its reliability. Researchers tested 127 ticks removed from 122 people in the Netherlands, and every rapid test was negative, even though 14 participants subsequently reported a rash characteristic of early Lyme disease (10 of them confirmed by their doctors). Importantly, PCR testing of remaining tick material from these 14 participants detected Lyme-related Borrelia DNA in 9 cases, despite the negative rapid-test results. The researchers concluded that the self-test was not suitable for predicting Lyme disease following a tick bite, as it missed all of the obvious early Lyme cases. Note: the product may have changed or possibly discontinued since that study, and its current performance and availability may differ. Read the study.

Unlike PCR, antigen-based lateral-flow tests do not amplify the target pathogen. They use antibodies and nanotechnology to strengthen a visible test line. In contrast, laboratory-based TaqMan PCR amplifies a pathogen’s DNA millions of times over and then uses ultra-sensitive fluorescent detection to typically detect down to 10-100 copies of a gene target. That’s why qPCR remains the gold standard for molecular pathogen detection.

Remember the at-home COVID test? Most of us took one, and many of us learned that a negative result wasn’t always the final word. Although the pandemic drove major improvements in lateral-flow ( antigen) tests, they still missed infections that laboratory PCR tests caught, especially early on, when there was less virus to detect. That’s why the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) advised people to repeat an at-home test after a negative result, and noted that a laboratory molecular (PCR) test is more sensitive. (FDA guidance)

 

What About Test Accuracy?

Lateral-flow tests typically detect proteins, while PCR tests use DNA sequences to more accurately distinguish between closely related pathogens.

At least 20 different disease-causing pathogens, including bacteria, viruses, and parasites, can be transmitted to humans by ticks in the United States (National Institutes of Health [NIH], 2019). Closely related organisms can share similar proteins, making them difficult for some antibody-based tests to distinguish.

Properly designed and validated PCR assays target specific DNA sequences that can differentiate disease-causing pathogens from less harmful relatives, reducing the risk of misleading results.

Is a Lyme Lateral-Flow Test Good Enough?

In the rush for answers, you may lose the opportunity to learn more from your tick bite.

Comic: a parent gets a negative at-home Lyme tick test result, but her child still gets sick
A single-pathogen test can return a negative result even when other tick-borne pathogens are present.

Whether positive or negative for Borrelia burgdorferi, a single-pathogen test cannot rule out other organisms associated with Lyme, anaplasmosis, babesiosis, ehrlichiosis, or spotted fever illnesses. Moreover, the testing process may destroy the sample, eliminating opportunities for additional testing or species identification.

Different tick species carry different pathogens, and some can harbor multiple disease-causing organisms. Identifying the tick is also important when assessing other tick-associated conditions, such as alpha-gal syndrome (AGS), associated primarily with lone star tick bites, or tick paralysis, which can be caused by several tick species.

 

Row of different tick species and life stages

So, What Treatment (If Any) Is Recommended After a Tick Bite?

It depends on which medical guidelines are followed. Recommendations for Lyme disease prophylaxis vary depending on the tick species, exposure circumstances, and medical guidelines followed.

Guidance for Antibiotic Prophylaxis After a Tick Bite: ILADS vs. IDSA

Should you take preventive antibiotics after a tick bite? Two medical organizations, the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) and the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), have published recommendations for preventing Lyme disease following certain tick bites.

Both guidelines focus on bites from Ixodes ticks capable of transmitting Lyme disease.

These include blacklegged (deer) ticks and western blacklegged ticks. However, the organizations differ in how they assess risk and when preventive antibiotics should be offered.

ILADS (2014) recommends promptly offering antibiotic prophylaxis when an Ixodes tick is known to have fed, regardless of how engorged the tick appears or the infection rate in the local tick population. ILADS emphasizes individualized medical decisions and shared decision-making.

IDSA (2020) takes a more restrictive approach, recommending prophylaxis only when all three criteria are met: the bite was from a Lyme-transmitting Ixodes species, it occurred in a highly endemic Lyme disease region, and the tick was attached for at least 36 hours. Prophylaxis must begin within 72 hours of tick removal.

Comparison of Antibiotic Prophylaxis Guidelines

Criteria ILADS (2014) IDSA (2020)
Tick species Ixodes tick Lyme-transmitting Ixodes tick
Evidence of feeding Tick must have fed Attachment ≥36 hours
Degree of engorgement No minimum required Used to help estimate attachment duration
Geographic risk No minimum local infection rate Highly endemic Lyme disease area required
Treatment timing Offer promptly Within 72 hours of removal
Antibiotic approach Extended doxycycline course (20 days) Single dose of doxycycline

Why Does Tick Identification Matter?

Medical guidelines emphasize tick species identification when considering preventive antibiotics for Lyme disease.

Accurate identification, along with information about feeding and geographic exposure, can help patients and physicians assess Lyme risk.

Current medical guidelines address preventive antibiotics after a tick bite only for Lyme disease. For other tick-borne illnesses, such as anaplasmosis, ehrlichiosis, babesiosis and spotted fever, there is no recommended preventive treatment; the standard advice is to watch for symptoms. That makes it all the more important to know which tick bit you and what it may have carried.
Comic: a parent reviews a Ticknology tick test report listing multiple pathogens and shares it with the doctor
Tick identification and multi-pathogen PCR testing give you and your doctor a fuller picture of your exposure.

Best Practices: A Modern Approach to Tick Bites

Preventing tick bites is always the best protection against tick-borne diseases. If you are bitten, preserve the tick and have it identified and tested through Ticknology (Priority: results in 24–72 hours, weekends included; or Standard: results in 3 business days), or identified for free through an online service such as the University of Rhode Island’s TickEncounter program. Learn to recognize the signs and symptoms of Lyme disease and other tick-borne illnesses, which can be subtle, nonspecific, and difficult to diagnose. Accurate tick identification, assessment of feeding, and comprehensive pathogen testing provide a more complete picture of potential exposure. Remember, tick testing cannot determine whether you have been infected. Consult a healthcare professional promptly if symptoms develop or you have concerns about preventive treatment.

References

  • Care Plus / Tropicare (2016). New Tick-Test now available in Canada. Source
  • Sprong H, et al. (2013). Sensitivity of a point of care tick-test for the development of Lyme borreliosis. Parasites & Vectors, 6:338. Source
  • U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Understanding At-Home OTC COVID-19 Antigen Diagnostic Test Results. Source
  • National Institutes of Health (2019). NIH strategic research plan addresses growing tickborne diseases threat. Source
  • ILADS (2014). Evidence assessments and guideline recommendations in Lyme disease. Source
  • IDSA/AAN/ACR (2020). Guidelines for the Prevention, Diagnosis and Treatment of Lyme Disease. Source
  • University of Rhode Island. TickEncounter program. Source
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Preventing Tick Bites. Source
  • LymeDisease.org. Lyme Disease Symptoms. Source

 

Tick-Borne Diseases and Lyme Cases are Growing in America

The data on these deadly diseases show year over year increases; it’s important to be aware and know that ticks are no longer restricted within the Northeast.

Lyme Disease is the #1 vector-borne disease in America, and deer ticks, who are responsible for most tick-borne disease and Lyme cases, are quickly expanding reach across the US. In fact, Hawaii is the only state without a reported case of Lyme Disease.

 


Did you know?

Ticks infect 6x more people with diseases than mosquitos.

Continue reading “Tick-Borne Diseases and Lyme Cases are Growing in America”

ASIAN LONGHORNED TICK FOUND IN CAMDEN COUNTY, NJ


Ticknology laboratory (Fort Collins, CO) has confirmed that a Longhorned tick (Haemaphysalis longicornis) was discovered at a residence in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. This is the first sighting and identification of the Asian longhorned tick in Camden Co.

An adult female Longhorned tick was recovered from a tick bite on August 2, 2019 and was subsequently submitted for identification and pathogen testing at Ticknology. The specimen was initially identified morphologically and then further confirmed by DNA sequencing of the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I gene.

The DNA sequence was compared to all genomic sequences available in National Center for Biotechnology Information databases.


Sequence analysis was performed using a 480 base pair query and the results are as follows:
Organism Score Number of Hits
Haemaphysalis longicornis 887 155
Specimen 2920.1 shared 100% identity with GenBank: MF666915.1, MF666912.1, MF666886.1, MF666885.1, JQ625691.1 and JF758635.1


In an unrelated case, another confirmed female Longhorned tick from Bergen County NJ was also submitted to Ticknology. This specimen was also found attached to a woman on August 12, 2019 at her residence. Both the Camden and Bergen ticks were tested for pathogens and were negative for the following pathogens: Borrelia burgdorferi (sensu lato), Borrelia general species, Borrelia mayonii, Borrelia miyamotoi, Bartonella general species, Anaplasma phagocytophilum, Babesia microti, Rickettsia rickettsii, Rickettsia parkeri, Ehrlichia chaffeensis, Ehrlichia ewingii, Francisella tularensis.

The reporting of human encounters with this exotic tick species in suburban environments further illustrates the need for continued surveillance of the Longhorned tick and its potential threat to both humans and agriculture.
Support passive tick and tick-borne disease surveillance by submitting your tick for identification and testing.

How to Save a Tick for Testing

Save your tick for testing!

If you have been bitten by a tick, sending it out for identification and laboratory testing is one of the most effective measures you can take to determine your risk of exposure to Lyme disease and other tick-borne illness. If you discover a tick, promptly remove it using either fine-tipped tweezers.

Tick Removal Using Tweezers
Source: https://www.cdc.gov/lyme/removal/index.html

Continue reading “How to Save a Tick for Testing”

Tick Bites Linked to Meat Allergy

Adult male and female Lone Star tick
Lone Star tick

A bite from a Lone Star tick may cause meat allergy.

 

Alpha-gal allergy, also known as meat allergy or mammalian meat allergy (MMA), is an immune reaction to galactose-alpha-1,3-galactose (alpha-gal). Although still controversial, it has been proposed that Lone star ticks (a.k.a Amblyomma americanum) have been linked to meat allergy. The alpha-gal sugar from the tick can be transmitted to the patient through a tick bite causing sensitization and ultimately allergic reactions to red meat. Continue reading “Tick Bites Linked to Meat Allergy”